You are not logged in! [Login]    
 

>Fakes, Frauds and Facelifts: How to identify counterfeit and altered Magic cards v3.0

1.0 There are fake Magic cards???
2.0 Am I in danger of being scammed?
3.0 How will I know one when I see one?
4.0 Some important things to know about the real cards
    4.1 A special word about Alternate 4th Edition
5.0 Some examples
6.0 Contributors
4.1 A special word about Alternate 4th Edition
In 1995, Wizards of the Coast contracted a US company named the United States Playing Card Corporation, from Cincinatti, Ohio to produce two sets of their other game Vampire: the Eternal Struggle. It is believed that at the same time they were also contracted to produce a domestic printing of 4th Edition in parallel with those already being produced by Carta Mundi in Belgium. An unknown amount of complete product was produced but never officially released due to legal disputes between the two companies. The product was scheduled to be destroyed, but in 1999 it was discovered that some of these cards leaked into public hands. These cards look and feel almost identical to normal 4th Edition cards. On close inspection though you will notice that the card stock is thicker and the finish is glossier. Since this company has different printers than Carta Mundi the exact printing patterns are slightly different as well. But most importantly, these cards are coated with a UV protective layer to prevent fading. Because of this coating these cards fail the blacklight test.

Any keen observer would quickly label them counterfeit, but there are many collector's who disagree. Since they technically are official WotC products, some consider them rarities and will actually pay a premium for them. This makes spotting fake 4th Edition cards particularly difficult. Once you have identified that the card you are holding is not a Carta Mundi produced card, how can you determine whether it's an Alternate 4th Edition card or not? None of the tests on this site will work, except a very detailed comparison. This of course requires owning an Alternate 4th Edition card to compare with. If you think you might have one, and you really need to know whether it's fake or just Alternate 4th, I can do the comparison for you. Fill out the contact form and let me know.
Previous Next

© copyright 1995-2008 Apathy House. Design by barcmo. Magic: the Gathering is a registered trademark of Wizards of the Coast.